Jeremiah Fisher: The Heart Of Cousins Beach And The Summer I Turned Pretty's Enduring Appeal
Since its debut on Amazon Prime in 2022, The Summer I Turned Pretty has captivated audiences with its sun-drenched Cousins Beach setting, poignant coming-of-age story, and, most notably, its compelling love triangle. Based on Jenny Han's bestselling novel trilogy, the series follows Belly Conklin as she navigates her feelings for two brothers, Conrad and Jeremiah Fisher. While fans often find themselves fiercely divided into "Team Conrad" or "Team Jeremiah," there's no denying the undeniable charm and emotional depth of Jeremiah Fisher, played by the talented Gavin Casalegno. He's a character who embodies the warmth of summer, yet carries a surprising amount of emotional weight, making him a central figure in Belly's journey and a favorite among many viewers.
Who is Jeremiah Fisher? A Deep Dive into Cousins Beach's Golden Boy
Meet one of Belly Conklin's primary love interests in The Summer I Turned Pretty, Jeremiah Fisher. He's introduced as Conrad's younger brother, a charismatic and playful lifeguard who quickly develops feelings for Belly. At 16 or 17 years old in both the novel and the TV show adaptation, Jeremiah is often portrayed as the opposite of his more broody older brother, Conrad. He’s the sunny, selfless, and incredibly kind presence that lights up a room, a stark contrast to Conrad's more guarded demeanor. This inherent warmth is a significant part of his appeal, drawing both Belly and the audience towards him.
The Charismatic Lifeguard with a Heart of Gold
Jeremiah's vibrant personality is infectious. He's the kind of person who always puts on a brave face, regardless of the turmoil that’s brewing barely a centimeter beneath the surface. Gavin Casalegno, who portrays Jeremiah, has even admitted to similarities with his character, telling V Magazine, "Jeremiah, quite frankly, is me in real life. When I got the character, I was like, 'Oh my gosh, this is so me.'" This authentic connection between actor and character undoubtedly contributes to Jeremiah's believable charm and relatability.
More Than Just a Smile: Jeremiah's Hidden Depths
Beneath the playful exterior, Jeremiah carries significant emotional burdens. He is sensitive and visibly hurt by Belly's often-clear preference for Conrad, a struggle that adds a layer of vulnerability to his character. Furthermore, a major plot point, especially in the later seasons, revolves around his mother's cancer. The devastating loss of his mother from cancer leaves him and Conrad grappling with profound grief, adding a heavier context to season 2 and beyond. Despite his own pain, Jeremiah consistently demonstrates immense kindness to Belly, always striving to be there for her, even when his own heart is aching.
The Heart of the Love Triangle: Jeremiah and Belly
The central love triangle in The Summer I Turned Pretty has everyone choosing sides, sparking passionate debates among fans. An expert often breaks down what it means to be 'Team Jeremiah' or 'Team Conrad,' but for many, Jeremiah's consistent affection and open heart make him a compelling choice for Belly.
From Friend to Love Interest: The Evolution of "Jelly"
Initially, Jeremiah had always cared for Belly in a brotherly sense, much like Conrad. He strictly saw her as "his best friend's little sister." However, as Belly grows and the summers at Cousins Beach unfold, Jeremiah's feelings deepen. Their connection evolves into something more profound, marked by moments of genuine tenderness and understanding. Author and showrunner Jenny Han has even described Belly and Jeremiah as having "Nala-Simba energy" in the final season, hinting at a deep, almost fated bond between them.
For #TeamJelly enthusiasts, Jeremiah's unwavering devotion is a major draw. In The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 2, a significant turning point occurs: Belly chooses Jeremiah over Conrad, marking the beginning of their relationship. This decision ignited cheers from fans who had rooted for the sunny brother, validating the kindness and effort Jeremiah consistently poured into their connection. "I spent so much of my life dreaming about what it would be like," reflects the sentiment of many who long for a love as dedicated as Jeremiah's.
Team Jeremiah vs. Team Conrad: The Ongoing Debate
Belly’s heart is constantly at war, a sentiment beautifully captured by a Taylor Swift lyric often referenced by fans: "I once believed love would be burning red…but loving him was red…" The web page argues that Jeremiah, the sunny and selfless brother, is often seen as the better romantic choice for Belly, the main character of the teen drama. His consistent support, emotional availability, and genuine happiness in Belly's presence often stand in contrast to Conrad's more complicated and at times distant nature. The battle between Team Jeremiah and Team Conrad has always been intense, and as we head into the final season, the stakes are getting higher.
Show vs. Book: The Evolution of Jeremiah
Fans of Jenny Han's original novel trilogy know that while the Amazon Prime series stays true to the spirit of the books, it also takes some creative liberties. One of the most notable changes concerns Jeremiah's character.
A Shift in Sexuality: From Book to Screen
In The Summer I Turned Pretty book, Jeremiah is straight. However, author and showrunner Jenny Han made a conscious decision to change his sexuality in the show, portraying him as bisexual. This update adds a layer of modern representation and depth to his character, allowing for a broader exploration of relationships and identity within the series. This is one of the key differences that stands out to fans when discussing how the show and books diverge.
The show, while based on the bestselling YA novel series, has carved its own path, with the third season adapting book three, "We'll Always Have Summer." This adaptation allows for new interpretations and developments, keeping both long-time book fans and new show viewers on their toes.
The Road Ahead: What's Next for Jeremiah?
Fans have followed Belly Conklin through her ups and downs with Conrad and Jeremiah Fisher, the brothers who both have feelings for her, and their collective struggle to find their way. The Summer I Turned Pretty’s third and final season will premiere in July 2025. First-look images from the final season have already been released, fueling anticipation. The season promises to delve deeper into the emotional aftermath of their mother's passing and the complexities of Belly's choice. As Gavin Casalegno notes, "We’re heading back to Cousins Beach this summer, and the stakes are getting higher."
With Season 2 being one of the 10 most-watched seasons of any series ever on Prime Video, the hype for the final season is incredibly high. Fans are theorizing how it’ll all end for Belly, Conrad, and Jeremiah, eagerly awaiting the resolution of this beloved love triangle. The final season will see Belly attending the same college as one of the brothers, further intertwining their lives.
Summary
Jeremiah Fisher is more than just a love interest in The Summer I Turned Pretty; he is a complex character whose journey from a playful lifeguard to a sensitive, resilient young man deeply impacts the series. His unwavering kindness, emotional depth, and ability to put on a brave face despite personal turmoil have endeared him to countless fans who passionately advocate for "Team Jeremiah." While the show introduces changes like his bisexuality from the book, it only adds to the richness of his portrayal by Gavin Casalegno. As the series heads into its highly anticipated final season, Jeremiah remains a pivotal figure, embodying the heart of Cousins Beach and the enduring appeal of a love story that has captured the imagination of a generation.
Jeremiah Fisher | The Summer I Turned Pretty Wiki | Fandom
The Summer I Turned Pretty: In a World of Conrads, Choose Jeremiah
Jeremiah Fisher | The Summer I turned pretty Wiki | Fandom
