Is Sabrina Carpenter Gay? Unpacking The Buzz Around Her Sexuality

Johnny Hegmann 01 Jul 2025

Sabrina Carpenter has swiftly ascended to pop stardom, captivating audiences with her catchy tunes like "Espresso" and her latest album, "Short n' Sweet." Beyond her undeniable musical talent, one question has consistently sparked major online buzz and captivated public interest: her sexuality. Is Sabrina Carpenter gay, bisexual, or is the discussion around her identity a clever form of queerbaiting? This article dives into the theories, controversial moments, and fan speculation surrounding Sabrina Carpenter's sexual orientation, drawing directly from the ongoing conversations online.

The Roots of the Rumors: Lyrics, Visuals, and Fan Theories

The speculation about Sabrina Carpenter's sexuality isn't new. Rumors about her being queer started because of various on-screen moments, lyrical interpretations, and fan observations. Fans and critics alike have been scrutinizing her lyrics and actions, searching for hints about her true identity. As one source puts it, "Sabrina Carpenter sexuality has sparked major online buzz—are her lyrics and actions hinting at bisexuality or is it clever queerbaiting?"

Early Whispers and Queer-Coded Moments

Even before her most recent album, certain performances and visual elements fueled the initial whispers. For instance, "Sabrina Carpenter’s 'Juno' performance was so gay, the stage nearly came out too," a statement that highlights how her stage presence and artistic choices have often been interpreted through a queer lens. These early moments set the stage for a deeper dive into her public persona and artistic expressions.

The "Gay Awakening" and Short n' Sweet

The release of her album, Short n' Sweet, significantly intensified the discussion. The album features lyrics that directly address or allude to queer themes, leading many fans to believe she was hinting at a "gay awakening."

One prominent lyric that caught immediate attention was, "Though Sabrina Carpenter laments on her new album, Short n’ Sweet, that 'the Lord forgot my gay awakening,' she..." This line alone ignited a firestorm of discussion among the LGBTQ+ community and her fanbase.
Another reference states, "Sabrina Carpenter leaves fans fanatic with a bold gay awakening on her latest album, Short n' Sweet." This suggests a deliberate choice to incorporate such themes, whether personal or artistic.
Further fueling this, "Sabrina Carpenter opened up about her celeb childhood crushes, and I guess the Lord truly did forget her gay awakening," adding a layer of personal reflection to the narrative.

A particular song off the record, "Slim Pickins," became a central topic of conversation amongst the gays. While some interpret it as "Sabrina Carpenter might have just confirmed the straight allegations in a brand new song," others point to the line where "Carpenter laments her heterosexuality" as a key indicator of her exploring or even wishing for a different path. This duality in interpretation underscores the ambiguity that often surrounds discussions of her sexuality.

The "Taste" Music Video and Jenna Ortega

Visuals play a crucial role in pop culture, and Sabrina Carpenter's music video for her single "Taste" certainly added fuel to the fire. "Sabrina Carpenter just dropped the music video for her new single “Taste,” which casts Jenna Ortega opposite her in a gory, campy romp." More explicitly, "Sabrina Carpenter and Jenna Ortega make out in the bloody new music video for Taste." This highly publicized on-screen kiss with a popular actress like Jenna Ortega naturally led to increased speculation about Carpenter's own sexual identity, prompting many to ask, "After the pop star released her latest video Taste, fans are speculating about her sexuality."

The "Queerbaiting" Debate and Public Scrutiny

With the rise of queer representation in media, the concept of "queerbaiting" has also become a prominent part of the conversation. This refers to creators hinting at LGBTQ+ relationships or themes without explicitly portraying them, often to attract a queer audience without alienating a broader, potentially less accepting, demographic. This brings us back to the question: are her lyrics and actions hinting at bisexuality or is it clever queerbaiting?

Navigating Ambiguity: Is it Representation or Queerbaiting?

The debate around Sabrina Carpenter's sexuality often boils down to this distinction. Some argue that her playful ambiguity and queer-coded content are a genuine exploration or representation, while others feel it's a strategic move to garner attention without committing to a label. "While it hasn't worked yet, the best way to get fans to think Carpenter might have secrets is to keep doing gay stuff," suggests one perspective, implying a deliberate strategy to maintain buzz. This ongoing debate about "Sabrina Carpenter’s new album cover has rekindled one of the classic debates around pop culture and sexuality, or is the debate itself the..." point, indicating that the discussion itself is part of the cultural phenomenon.

The "Busy Woman" Lyric Controversy

Not all of the discussion has been positive. A particular lyric from her bonus track "Busy Woman" sparked significant backlash. "Carpenter's reference to deeming someone gay in her new song after being rejected is raising the internet's eyebrows." The full lyric, "[intro] (oh, hey) oh [verse 1] I'm so mature, collected and sensible except when I get hit with rejection to turn me down, well, that's just unethical I'll turn into someone you're..." followed by the controversial line "I'll just deem you gay," led to accusations of homophobia. "Sabrina Carpenter is getting dragged for 'I'll just deem you gay' lyric on new song Busy Woman compared to Picture to Burn by Taylor Swift homophobic." This incident complicated the narrative, making some question the authenticity of her queer-coded messaging.

SNL's Take and Public Demand for Answers

The public's desire for clarity on Sabrina Carpenter's sexuality even made its way to mainstream comedy. "Why doesn’t anyone think Sabrina Carpenter is gay?" asked SNL's Jane Wickline, demanding answers. "Finally, someone said it!" This sentiment was echoed by many fans. "Jane Wickline does a bit on SNL about Sabrina Carpenter's undeserved lack of queer rumors," highlighting the perceived discrepancy between her suggestive content and the relatively muted public speculation compared to other pop stars. This SNL sketch underscored the widespread curiosity and the feeling among some that her sexuality remained an open, yet unaddressed, question.

Sabrina's Stance: Embracing Sexuality and Personal Privacy

Amidst all the theories and controversies, Sabrina Carpenter herself has spoken about embracing her sexuality and the scrutiny that comes with it. She has been in the limelight for various reasons, including her stance on LGBTQ+ issues, but one question that often remains is about her personal identity.

Her Own Words on Sexuality and Backlash

The "Espresso" hitmaker has opened up about receiving backlash for embracing her sexuality. "Sabrina Carpenter on being criticized for embracing her sexuality and holding that space in pop after Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera," shows her awareness of the historical context of female pop stars and public scrutiny. She also stated, "Sabrina Carpenter expertly embraces her sexuality without succumbing to the “male gaze,” and this is why I think it’s kind of a big deal," suggesting a conscious effort to control her narrative and presentation.

In interviews, "Sabrina Carpenter opens up about her new album, 'Man’s Best Friend,' her single Manchild, online scrutiny, her relationships and much more," indicating she is aware of the intense public interest in her private life, including her romantic relationships.

The Unconfirmed Truth

Despite all the buzz, "Some people believe Sabrina Carpenter is gay or bisexual, but she hasn't announced anything about her sexuality to the public." This is the crux of the matter. While her music, visuals, and public persona often lean into queer themes, she has not explicitly labeled her sexual orientation. Interestingly, some interpretations suggest a counter-narrative: "While Sabrina Carpenter is straight, some of her statements and lyrics make her fans think she is gay." This highlights the gap between artistic expression, fan interpretation, and personal identity. The line from "Slim Pickins" where she "lamented her heterosexuality" could be seen as a playful nod to the conversation rather than a definitive statement of identity.

As Sabrina herself once mused, "Well, a lot of people like to start these juicy gay rumors about whether pop stars are gay, and this is a new song that I, Sabrina Carpenter, wrote called 'When Will Even One...'" This suggests a self-awareness of the rumors and perhaps a playful engagement with them through her art.

In summary, the question of "Is Sabrina Carpenter gay?" remains officially unanswered by the artist herself. Her music, particularly the album "Short n' Sweet" with its "gay awakening" themes and the song "Slim Pickins" lamenting heterosexuality, alongside the highly publicized "Taste" music video featuring Jenna Ortega, has fueled widespread speculation about her sexuality. While some interpret these as hints towards a queer identity, others view them as artistic expression or even "queerbaiting." The controversy surrounding her "Busy Woman" lyric further complicated the narrative. Sabrina Carpenter has openly discussed embracing her sexuality and navigating public scrutiny, but she has not publicly confirmed a specific sexual orientation beyond what is implied or interpreted from her art. Ultimately, the ongoing discussion reflects a broader cultural conversation about identity, representation, and the boundaries between an artist's public persona and their private life, leaving fans to continue to "Check out this article for more information about Sabrina Carpenter’s sexual orientation and her past and current relationships" as the conversation evolves.

Netflix’s Sabrina reboot takes time to get wicked, but then it’s

260x285 Resolution The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Season 2 260x285

"Sabrina, the Teenage Witch" cast reunited at L.A. Comic-ConHelloGiggles

Challenges And Resilience